Acreage For Sale

A BUILDER'S MASTERPIECE AWAITS: 4.8 ACRES OF PRIME WATERFRONT IN O-CONEE ESTATES. Rarely does an opportunity of this magnitude and prestige surface on Long Island's South Shore. We are proud to present 2 Garner Lane, an unprecedented 4.8-acre blank canvas nestled within the guarded gates of the legendary O-Conee Estates. This is not merely land; it is a developer's crown jewel, offering the rarest of chances to create a legacy waterfront compound or a highly profitable, ultra-luxury subdivision. Boasting sweeping frontage on private Manatuck Lake, the location is synonymous with discretion and grandeur. While ideal for a single, expansive *Great Gatsby* style estate, the true *highest and best use* lies in the property's subdivision potential into two grand, ~2.4-acre waterfront lots. Future residents will enjoy private lake access and exclusive HOA amenities, including private marinas with direct Great South Bay access and a private beach. With the path to multi-million dollar builds cleared, this shovel-ready opportunity is a high-reward asset for custom builders and visionary developers alike. This lot is ready to make real estate history.

Property Details

  • Location: (private lake, pond, coastal)
  • Acres: 4.800
  • Waterfront: Yes
  • Waterview: Yes
  • ViewTypes: Lake
  • County: Suffolk County
  • Community: O-Conee Estates
  • Property Taxes: $27,219
  • MLS #: 971210

Location

Click on map to activate
(Open in Google Maps)   (Bing Map)  (Mapquest Map)

Contact Information:

Contact Agent
Listing Agent: Brian Montross, Laffey International Realt Estate, 631-672-0132, 516-224-4600 Listing Site, Listing Status: Active
Copyright © 2026 OneKey MLS. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.

Ad Statistics:

Lake Acreage For Sale in Bay Shore, New York
Ad Number : 7397549
Viewed: 0 times
Added: Mar 13, 2026
Updated on: Mar 13, 2026
All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.