Buy
Alabama
Alaska
Arizona
Arkansas
California
Colorado
Connecticut
Delaware
Florida
Georgia
Hawaii
Idaho
Montana
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Kansas
Kentucky
Louisiana
Maine
Maryland
Massachusetts
Michigan
Minnesota
Mississippi
Missouri
Nebraska
Nevada
New Hampshire
New Jersey
New Mexico
New York
North Carolina
North Dakota
Ohio
Oklahoma
Oregon
Pennsylvania
Rhode Island
South Carolina
South Dakota
Tennessee
Texas
Utah
Vermont
Virginia
Washington
West Virginia
Wisconsin
Wyoming
Canada & International Listings
ADVANCED SEARCH
Sell
Rent
Find an Agent
My Account
Login
Manage My Real Estate Ads
Manage My Rental Ads
Manage My Search Profile / Auto Notify
My Account Info
Manage My Favorites
Change My Email Address or Password
Advertise
Lake Real Estate
Lake Rentals
Join
<
Home
>
Indiana
>
Lake Shafer
- Select State -
Alabama
Alaska
Arizona
Arkansas
California
Colorado
Connecticut
Delaware
District of Columbia
Florida
Georgia
Hawaii
Idaho
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Kansas
Kentucky
Louisiana
Maine
Maryland
Massachusetts
Michigan
Minnesota
Mississippi
Missouri
Montana
Nebraska
Nevada
New Hampshire
New Jersey
New Mexico
New York
North Carolina
North Dakota
Ohio
Oklahoma
Oregon
Pennsylvania
Rhode Island
South Carolina
South Dakota
Tennessee
Texas
Utah
Vermont
Virginia
Washington
West Virginia
Wisconsin
Wyoming
- Select Lake -
(private lake, pond, creek)
Adams Lake
Atwood Lake
Ball Lake
Banning Lake
Barnes Lake
Bass Lake
Bear Lake
Beaver Dam Lake
Beck Lake
Big Barbee Lake
Big Bass Lake
Big Bower Lake
Big Cedar Lake
Big Chapman Lake
Big Lake
Big Long Lake
Big Otter Lake
Big Turkey Lake
Bischoff Reservoir
Bixler Lake
Blackman Lake
Blue Lake - Warrick County
Blue Lake - Whitley County
Boggs Lake
Brookville Lake
Bruce Lake
Cagles Mill Lake
Caldwell Lake
Camelot Lake
Carr Lake
Cedar Lake - LaGrange County
Cedar Lake - Lake County
Cedarville Reservoir
Center Lake
Christmas Lake
Clear Lake
Cook Lake
Cordry Lake
Crooked Lake - Steuben County
Crooked Lake - Whitley County
Dallas Lake
Dewart Lake
Diamond Lake
Doubletree Lake
Eagle Creek Reservoir
Elkhart River
Emma Lake
Falling Waters Lake
Fish Lake - LaGrange County
Fox Lake
Foxcliff Lakes
French Lake
Fryback Lake
Geist Reservoir
Glen Flint Lake
Goose Lake - Kosciusko County
Goose Lake - Whitley County
Gooseneck Lake
Grandview Lake
Griffy Lake
Hackenberg Lake
Hall Lake
Hamilton Lake
Harrison Lake
Hartz Lake
Heaton Lake
Heritage Lake
Hidden Valley Lake
Hill Lake
Hoffman Lake
Holem Lake
Hudson Lake
Indian Lake
Irish Lake
James Lake
Jimmerson Lake
Jones Lake
Kekionga Lake
Ken-Ray Lake
Knapp Lake
Kodiak Lake
Koontz Lake
Kreighbaum Lake
Kuhn Lake
Lake Charles West
Lake Clearwater
Lake Dalecarlia
Lake Eliza
Lake Freeman
Lake Gage
Lake George - Lake County
Lake George - Steuben County
Lake Helmerich
Lake Holiday - Lake County
Lake Holiday - Morgan County
Lake Holiday - Porter County
Lake Holly
Lake Hollybrook
Lake James
Lake LaSalle
Lake LaTonka
Lake Lemon
Lake Louise
Lake Manitou
Lake Maxinkuckee
Lake Michigan - Lake County
Lake Michigan - LaPorte County
Lake Michigan - Porter County
Lake Monroe
Lake Noel
Lake of the Woods - Lagrange County
Lake of the Woods - Marshall County
Lake Pleasant
Lake Santee
Lake Shafer
Lake Syl-van
Lake Tippecanoe
Lake Wawasee
Lake Woodland
Lamb Lake
Lilly Lake
Lime Lake
Little Barbee Lake
Little Cedar Lake
Little Long Lake - Steuben County
Little Nebo Lake
Little Otter Lake
Long Lake - Porter County
Loomis Lake
Loon Lake
Lower Long Lake - Noble County
Maumee River
McClures Lake
Mirror Lake
Morse Lake
Myers Lake
North Chain Lake
North Twin Lake
Nyona Lake
Ohio River - Floyd County
Ohio River - Perry County
Ohio River - Switzerland County
Ohio River - Vanderburgh County
Palestine Lake
Papakeechie Lake
Patoka Lake
Patton Lake
Pike Lake
Pine Canyon Lake
Pine Lake - LaPorte County
Pleasant Lake
Pretty Lake - LaGrange County
Princes East Lake
Princes Hants Lake
Princes Marlin Lake
Raccoon Lake / Cecil M. Harden
Riddles Lake
Ridinger Lake
Rocky Fork Lake
Round Lake - Noble County
Round Lake - Whitley County
Royer Lake
Saw Mill Lake
Schaefer Lake
Schockopee Lake
Sechrist Lake
Shoe Lake
Shriner Lake
Silver Lake
Simonton Lake
Skinner Lake
Smalley Lake
Snow Lake
South Twin Lake
St. Joseph River
Stanton Lake
Steinbarger Lake
Sullivan Lake
Sweetwater Lake
Sylvan Lake
Syracuse Lake
Tamarack Lake
The Backwaters Lake
Tippecanoe River - Fulton County
Tippecanoe River - Kosciusko County
Tippecanoe River - Marshall County
Tippecanoe River - White County
Tipton Lakes
Upper Fish Lake
Van Bibber Lake
Waldron Lake
Wall Lake
Waterstone Lake
Webster Lake
West Otter Lake
White River
Winona Lake
Witmer Lake
Yellow Bank Lake
Yellow Creek Lake
Waterfront
Any
Yes
No
Price
-
0
$100,000
$100,000+
$200,000
$200,000+
$300,000
$300,000+
$400,000
$400,000+
$500,000
$500,000+
$600,000
$600,000+
$700,000
$700,000+
$800,000
$800,000+
$900,000
Any Price
Any Price
Beds & Baths
Bedrooms
-
Baths
0+
1+
1.5+
2+
3+
4+
5+
6+
Type
Home
Lot
Acreage
Condo
Apartment
Townhome/Townhouse
Commercial
Other
House Boat
ALL
Sale Status
ALL
For Sale
Under Contract
Sale Pending
SOLD!
More
Open House
Any
Yes
Pool
Any
Yes
No
Square Feet
-
Lot Size, acres
-
Year Built
-
MLS #
Ad #
Time on Site
Click Here to Select
All ads
Ads updated or added within the last 24 hours
Ads updated or added the last 3 days
Ads updated or added last 7 days
Ads updated or added last 30 days
Reset filters
Streets
Satellite
Lake Shafer Homes For Sale
(21-35 of 35)
Sort By: Featured First
Type - A to Z
Type - Z to A
Price - Low to High
Price - High to Low
Waterfront - Yes to No
Waterfront - No to Yes
Sq Ft - Low to High
Sq Ft - High to Low
Acres - Low to High
Acres - High to Low
Year Built - High to Low
Year Built - Low to High
City - A to Z
City - Z to A
State - A to Z
State - Z to A
Date Added - Newest
Date Added - Oldest
Grid
Map
FILTERS
For Sale
$309,900
Adorable lake cottage with private dock now offered for sale on...
Lakefront
Home Monticello, Indiana
5255 E Bay Front Court
2
1.0
Sf: 840 Yr: 1960 Acres: 0.208
Ad # 6009276
For Sale
$309,000
Updated and all new!! This beautiful home has been completely...
Lakefront
Home Monticello, Indiana
5124 N Point Park Court
3
2.0
Sf: 2292 Yr: 1945 Acres: 0.650
Ad # 6010351
For Sale
$299,000
Location, Location, Location. This property offers convenient...
Home Monticello, Indiana
2055 N Norway Trail
3
2.0
Sf: 1248 Yr: 2003 Acres: 3.500
Ad # 6124105
For Sale
$279,900
2 bedroom Main Lake Shafer Cottage with Wide Panoramic Views of...
Lakefront
Home Monticello, Indiana
5063 NW Shafer Drive
2
1.0
Sf: 368 Yr: 1940 Acres: 0.285
Ad # 6009931
For Sale
$279,900
Lake Shafer Main Lake Lot with 24x48 Pole Barn Built by FBI. 2...
Lakefront
Lot Monticello, Indiana
5051 NW Shafer Drive
Acres: 0.265
Ad # 6009932
SPONSORED AD:
For Sale
$224,900
Looking for that lake level ranch with extra lot? Here it is 2...
Lakefront
Home Monticello, Indiana
3727 E Polk Loop
2
2.0
Sf: 1244 Yr: 1970 Acres: 0.275
Ad # 6099424
For Sale
$179,900
PRICE REDUCED !! Main Lake Shafer lot with 147' of waterfrontage...
Lakefront
Lot Monticello, Indiana
W Shafer Drive
Acres: 0.310
Ad # 5657116
For Sale
$164,900
2.01 acres of partially cleared B-2 Business Ground Adjacent to...
Commercial Monticello, Indiana
0 West Shafer Drive
0
0.0
Yr: 1801 Acres: 2.010
Ad # 4577046
For Sale
$160,000
Welcome to 4341 E Cherry Drive in Monticello! This charming...
Home Monticello, Indiana
4341 E Cherry Drive
3
1.0
Sf: 1152 Yr: 1972 Acres: 0.600
Ad # 4982183
For Sale
$19,900
partially wooded pond lot across street from Upper Lake Freeman...
Lot Monticello, Indiana
Tract A Brandywine Lane
Acres: 0.820
Ad # 3499607
Featured
Sale Pending
$469,900
Charming 3 bed, 1 bath lake cottage with a newly renovated...
Lakefront
Home Monticello, Indiana
3336 E Bailey Road
5
2.0
Sf: 1508 Yr: 1948 Acres: 0.460
Nathan Walts, Agent
Ad # 6111647
Featured
Sale Pending
$350,000
Lake Shafer Resort Property - A Prime Lakefront Retreat near...
Lakefront
Commercial Monticello, Indiana
4945 E Indiana Beach Road
8
8.5
Sf: 2670 Yr: 1953 Acres: 0.240
John Koppelmann, CRS, e-PRO, GRI, SRES, Agent
Ad # 5746301
Sale Pending
$285,900
Start making memories today! This charming 3 bedroom/2 bath home...
Lakefront
Home Monon, Indiana
6468 N Bedford Bay
3
2.0
Sf: 1296 Yr: 2006 Acres: 0.406
Ad # 6167233
Sale Pending
$275,000
Welcome to your dream lakefront getaway on beautiful Lake Shafer...
Lakefront
Home Monticello, Indiana
6019 E Liberty Drive
3
2.0
Sf: 1560 Yr: 2002 Acres: 0.120
Ad # 6023503
Sale Pending
$199,900
This beautifully updated Lake Shafer home offers stunning views...
Lakefront
Home Monticello, Indiana
2371 Untalulti Drive Unit #9
1
1.0
Sf: 468 Yr: 1918 Acres: 0.023
Ad # 6023504
<
1
2
CLOSE
Lake Shafer Real Estate Specialist
Be Smart, Call Bart
Bart Hickman
, Real Estate Network
Lake Shafer and Lake Freeman, Monticello, IN 47960
+1 Cell: 574-870-4269
View Listings
Contact Agent
We use cookies to offer you a better, more personalized browsing experience. By using this website, you are giving your consent for us to use cookies.
Read our
Privacy Policy
and
Cookie Policy
.
Accept
Deny