Buy
Search All Lake Properties For Sale
Advanced Search
Search by Zip Code Radius
Search for Ad # or MLS #
Search for Ad #
Latest Ads by State
Find Lake Lots & Acreage
Find Open Houses
Find Auctions
Find Foreclosures
Sell
Rent
Rent
Find an Agent
My Account
Login
Manage My Real Estate Ads
Manage My Rental Ads
Manage My Search Profile / Auto Notify
My Account Info
Manage My Favorites
Change My Email Address or Password
Logout
My Account
Login
Manage My Real Estate Ads
Manage My Rental Ads
Manage My Search Profile / Auto Notify
My Account Info
Manage My Favorites
Change My Email Address or Password
Logout
Advertise
Lake Real Estate
Beach Rentals
Lake Rentals
Join
Home
>
New York
>
Cayuga Lake
<
- Select State -
Alabama
Alaska
Arizona
Arkansas
California
Colorado
Connecticut
Delaware
District of Columbia
Florida
Georgia
Hawaii
Idaho
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Kansas
Kentucky
Louisiana
Maine
Maryland
Massachusetts
Michigan
Minnesota
Mississippi
Missouri
Montana
Nebraska
Nevada
New Hampshire
New Jersey
New Mexico
New York
North Carolina
North Dakota
Ohio
Oklahoma
Oregon
Pennsylvania
Rhode Island
South Carolina
South Dakota
Tennessee
Texas
Utah
Vermont
Virginia
Washington
West Virginia
Wisconsin
Wyoming
- Select Lake -
(private lake, pond, creek)
Adirondack Lake
Ainsworth Lake / Thirsty Pond
Alcove Reservoir
Alpine Lake
Amawalk Reservoir
Amity Lake
Amityville River
Arbuckle Pond
Aspen Lake
Atlantic Ocean - Lower Bay
Augar Lake
Ausable River
Babcock Lake
Baldwin Bay
Basha Kill Marsh Lake
Bass Lake - Franklin County
Battenkill River
Beaver Dam Lake
Beaver Lake - Sullivan County
Beaver Pond
Beaver Pond
Beaver River
Beaverkill River
Big Fresh Pond
Big Moose Lake
Black Lake - St. Lawrence County
Black Lake - Sullivan County
Black River - Jefferson County
Black River - Lewis County
Black River Bay
Blake Falls Reservoir
Blind Sodus Bay Lake
Blue Mountain Lake
Blueberry Lake
Bodine Lake
Bouquest River
Brackett Lake
Brant Lake
Brantingham Lake
Briscoe Lake
Bronx River
Browns River
Burden Lake
Butterfield Lake
Canada Lake
Canadarago Lake
Canandaigua Lake
Cannonsville Reservoir
Carmans River
Cassadaga Lakes
Cayuga Lake
Cayuta Lake
Cazenovia Lake
Cedar Lake
Cedar River
Chain Lake
Charley Lake
Chateaugay River
Chaumont Bay
Chaumont River
Chautauqua Lake
Chazy Lake
Chazy River
Chenango Lake
Chenango River
Chubb River Lake
Church Pond
Cincinnatus Lake
Clove Lakes
Columbia Lake
Conesus Lake
Conifer Lake
Connectquot River
Copake Lake
Cortlandt Lake
Cossayuna Lake
Cranberry Lake
Cranberry Pond
Cranberry Pond
Crooked Lake
Cross Lake
Cross River Reservoir
Croton River
Crystal Lake - Albany County
Crystal Lake - Delaware County
Crystal Lake - Jefferson County
Crystal Lake - Rensselaer County
Crystal Lake - Sullivan County
Crystal Lake - Warren County
Cuba Lake
Deer River
Delaware River - Delaware County
Delaware River - Orange County
Delaware River - Sullivan County
Delta Lake
Deruyter Lake
Duane Lake
Duck Lake
Dyken Pond
Eagle Pond
East Caroga Lake
East River - Bronx County
East River - Kings County
East River - New York County
East River - Queens County
East Stoner Lake
Echo Lake
Echo Lake
Erie Lake
Fawn Lake
Fern Lake
Findley Lake
First Lake
Forest Lake
Forestport Reservoir
Forge River
Fourth Lake
Francis Pond
Freeport Bay
Friends Lake
Galway Lake
Garoga Lake
Genesee River
Glass Lake
Glen Lake
Goodnow Flow Lake
Goodyear Lake
Grassy Sprain Lake
Great Chazy River
Great Peconic Bay
Great Pond
Great Sacandaga Lake
Great South Bay
Green Chazy River
Green Lake
Green River
Greenwood Lake
Guffin Bay
Guilford Lake
Gull Pond
Hadlock Pond
Hampstead Bay
Harlem River
Harris Lake
Harrisburg Lake
Hatch Lake
Highland Lake
Highland Lake
Highland Lake - Sullivan County
Higley Flow
Hinckley Reservoir
Honeoye Lake
Hope Lake
Hudson River - Albany County
Hudson River - Bronx County
Hudson River - Columbia County
Hudson River - Dutchess County
Hudson River - Fulton County
Hudson River - Greene County
Hudson River - New York County
Hudson River - Orange County
Hudson River - Putnam County
Hudson River - Rensselaer County
Hudson River - Rockland County
Hudson River - Ulster County
Hudson River - Warren County
Hudson River - Westchester County
Hunns Lake
Hunter Lake
Hyde Lake
Indian Lake - Hamilton County
Indian Lake - Putnam County
Indian River - St. Lawrence County
Irondequoit Bay
Jamaica Bay
Jones Bay
Kasoag Lake
Kayuta Lake
Kelm Pond
Kenoza Lake
Keuka Lake
Kinderhook Lake
Kirk Lake
Kyser Lake
Lake Abanakee
Lake Algonquin
Lake Bonaparte
Lake Carmel
Lake Champlain - Clinton County
Lake Champlain - Essex County
Lake Clear Outlet
Lake DeForest
Lake Demons / Demons Pond
Lake Desolation
Lake Devenoge
Lake Diana
Lake Dixon
Lake Durant
Lake Eaton
Lake Edward
Lake Elizabeth - Rensselaer County
Lake Elizabeth - Saratoga County
Lake Erie
Lake Flower
Lake Frances
Lake Gay
Lake George
Lake Gerry
Lake Hawthorne
Lake Huntington
Lake in the Sky
Lake Innisfree
Lake Joseph
Lake Lauderdale
Lake Lonely
Lake Louise Marie
Lake Luzerne
Lake Mae
Lake Mahopac
Lake Margarite
Lake Mohegan
Lake Moraine
Lake of the Woods
Lake Ontario - Jefferson County
Lake Ontario - Monroe County
Lake Ontario - Niagara County
Lake Ontario - Orleans County
Lake Ontario - Oswego County
Lake Ontario - Sodus Bay
Lake Ontario - Wayne County
Lake Panamoka
Lake Peekskill
Lake Pennock
Lake Placid
Lake Pleasant
Lake Pocatello
Lake Ronkonkoma
Lake Secor
Lake Serenity
Lake Snow
Lake Sunnyside
Lake Tekeni
Lake Titus
Lake Waccsbuc
Lake Weil
Lake Colby
Lamoka Lake
Larchwood Lake
Lebanon Reservoir
Lelands Pond
Lily Lake - Ulster County
Lime Lake
Lincoln Pond
Little Chazy River
Little Neck Bay
Little River
Little Salmon River
Little Sodus Bay
Little Wolf Pond
Little York Lake
Littles Lake
Loch Ada Lake
Loch Sheldrake
Long Island Sound
Long Lake - Hamilton County
Long Pond - Columbia County
Loon Lake
Loon Lake
Lower Lake Ninham
Lower Little York Lake
Lower Saranac Lake
Lucas Kill
Mad River
Mamaroneck River
Mariaville Lake
Masten Lake
McAuleys Lake
Meadow Lake
Merriewold Lake
Mettowee River
Middle Bay
Middle Branch Moose River
Middle Branch Reservoir
Mill River
Minerva Lake
Mirror Lake
Mohawk River
Montauk Lake
Moody Pond
Moon Lake
Moose River - Lewis County
Moriches Bay
Mountain Lake - Fulton County
Mountain Lake - Sullivan County
Mountain View Lake
Nassau Lake
Neversink River
New Croton Reservoir
New Lake
Newark Bay
Newkirk Lake
Niagara River
Nissequogue River - Suffolk County
North Pond - Chenango County
North Pond - Oswego County
North Sandy Pond
Oak Orchard River
Oakland Lake
Old Forge Pond
Onderdonk Lake
Oneida Lake
Oneida River
Onondaga Lake
Oquaga Lake
Orange Lake
Oscawana Lake
Ostelic River
Oswegatchie River - Jefferson County
Oswegatchie River - Lewis County
Oswegatchie River - St. Lawrence County
Oswegatchie River - West Branch
Oswego River
Otisco Lake
Otsego Lake
Otter Lake - Oneida County
Owasco Lake
Owasco River
Paradise Lake
Paradox Lake
Parsonage Cove
Peach Lake
Pecks Lake
Peconic River
Pepacton Reservoir
Pine Laken - Sullivan County
Pine Pond
Piseco Lake
Pleasant Lake - Fulton County
Pleasant Lake - Lewis County
Pleasure Lake
Plymouth Reservoir
Pocantico Lake
Port Bay
Putnam Lake
Queechy Lake
Rainbow Lake
Ramapo River - Orange County
Raquette Lake
Raquette River - St. Lawrence County
Raritan Bay
Roaring Brook Lake
Robinson Pond
Rondaxe Lake
Round Lake
Rushford Lake
Sacandaga Lake - Hamilton County
Sacandaga River
Sackett Lake
Salmon River - Clinton County
Salmon River - Franklin County
Salmon River - Oswego County
Salmon River Reservoir
Sand Pond - Callicoon County
Sandy Pond - Oswego County
Saranac River
Saratoga Lake
Schoharie Reservoir
Schoolhouse Lake
Schroon Lake
Schroon River
Second Lake
Seneca Lake
Seneca River
Sepasco Lake
Seven Hills Lake
Seward Lake
Shandelee Lake
Shawangunk Kill River
Shinnecock Bay
Sidewell Lke
Silver Lake - Delaware County
Silver Lake - Dutchess County
Silver Lake - Wyoming County
Sisley Ponds
Skaneateles Lake
Sleepy Hollow Lake
Soft Maple Lake
South Colton Reservoir
Sparrowhawk Lake
Spencer Lake
Spring Brook Lake
Spring Lake
Spring Lakes
St. Lawrence River - Jefferson County
St. Lawrence River - Lake of the Isles
St. Lawrence River - St. Lawrence County
St. Regis River
Star Lake
Stone Hill River
Strawberry Lake
Strolowitz Lake
Summit Lake - Schoharie County
Summit Lake - Washington County
Susquehanna River - Broome County
Susquehanna River - Chenango County
Susquehanna River - Delaware County
Susquehanna River - Otsego County
Susquehanna River - Tioga County
Swan Lake
Swinging Bridge Lake
Sylvan Lake
Tanzman Lake
Ten Mile River - Dutchess County
Tennanah Lake
The Narrows
Third Lake
Timber Lake
Tioughnioga River - Broome County
Tioughnioga River - Cortland County
Toasperns Pond
Tomahawk Lake
Tomkins Lake
Treasure Lake
Triangle Lake
Tripp Lake
Trout Lake - Warren County
Trout River
Tunis Lake
Tupper Lake
Tuxedo Lake
Twin Hill Lake
Twin Island Lake
Twin Lakes
Unadilla River - Chenango County
Unadilla River - Otsego County
Upper Chateaugay Lake
Upper New York Bay
Upper Rhoda Pond
Upper Saranac Lake
Upper St Regis Lake
Upton Lake
Valentine Pond
Wallkill River
Wallkill River - Ulster County
Walloomsac River
Walton Lake
Waneta Lake
Warners Lake
Washington Lake
Wee Wah Lake
Weiden Lake
Wesslauf Pond
West Branch Delaware River
West Caroga Lake
West Stoner Lake
Whaleneck River
Whaley Lake
White Lake - Oneida County
White Lake - Sullivan County
Whiting Hollow Lake
Willow Lake
Wixon Pond
Wolf Lake
Wolf Pond
Wonder Lake
Woodland Reservoir
Yankee Lake
York Lake
Waterfront
Any
Yes
No
Price
-
0
$100,000
$50,000+
$200,000
$75,000+
$300,000
$100,000+
$400,000
$150,000+
$500,000
$200,000+
$600,000
$250,000+
$700,000
$300,000+
$800,000
$400,000+
Any Price
$500,000+
Beds & Baths
Bedrooms
-
Baths
0+
1+
1.5+
2+
3+
4+
5+
6+
Type
Home
Lot
Acreage
Condo
Apartment
Townhome/Townhouse
Commercial
ALL
Sale Status
ALL
For Sale
Under Contract
Sale Pending
SOLD!
More
Pool
Any
Yes
No
Square Feet
-
Lot Size, acres
-
Year Built
-
MLS #
Ad #
Time on Site
Click Here to Select
All ads
Ads updated or added within the last 24 hours
Ads updated or added the last 3 days
Ads updated or added last 7 days
Ads updated or added last 30 days
Cayuga Lake Homes For Sale
If you re considering lake homes for sale in New York, Cayuga Lake should be a strong contender. Carved out of the land by glaciers thousands of years ago, Cayuga Lake is the longest of the state s Finger Lakes and is also one of the deepest. The lake is a recreation haven year-round, catering to boaters, hunters, anglers, hikers, and even bird watchers. The surrounding areas are also steeped in culture and creativity, ensuring your Cayuga Lake experience will be engaging an
Learn more about Cayuga Lake...
(21-39 of 39)
Sort By: Featured First
Type - A to Z
Type - Z to A
Price - Low to High
Price - High to Low
Waterfront - Yes to No
Waterfront - No to Yes
Sq Ft - Low to High
Sq Ft - High to Low
Acres - Low to High
Acres - High to Low
Year Built - High to Low
Year Built - Low to High
Date Added - Newest
Date Added - Oldest
Grid
Map
FILTERS
For Sale
$345,000
Imagine the possibilities with this charming Victorian, 4-unit...
Cayuga Lake
,
Aurora
,
New York
5
5.0
Home For Sale
Sq Ft: 3472 Year: 1897 Acres: 1.500
Ad # 2054429
For Sale
$319,900
Lovely, open-concept ranch home 3/4 bedrooms 2.5 baths on nearly...
Cayuga Lake
,
Seneca Falls
,
New York
3
3.0
Waterfront
Home For Sale
Sq Ft: 2196 Year: 1963 Acres: 1.650
Ad # 2126672
For Sale
$269,000
Cayuga lake lot on west side of lake 100 foot of frontage and is...
Cayuga Lake
,
Seneca Falls
,
New York
Waterfront
Lot For Sale
Acres: 1.300
Ad # 1214728
For Sale
$230,000
This 8 acre parcel of land is situated above Cayuga Lake on a...
Cayuga Lake
,
Lansing
,
New York
Acreage For Sale
Acres: 8.000
Ad # 1837957
For Sale
$164,900
OPEN HOUSE SAT 10/23, 2-6pm. Enjoy year-round lake life living...
Cayuga Lake
,
Seneca Falls
,
New York
3
2.0
Waterfront
Home For Sale
Sq Ft: 1194 Year: 1951 Acres: 0.690
Ad # 2122955
For Sale
$160,000
Build the home of your dreams surrounded by the beauty of the...
Cayuga Lake
,
Trumansburg
,
New York
Waterfront
Lot For Sale
Acres: 1.470
Ad # 840613
For Sale
$87,000
High on a hill top with with views of Cayuga Lake. This could be...
Cayuga Lake
,
Lansing
,
New York
Lot For Sale
Acres: 0.000
Ad # 1837976
For Sale
$12,500
A great spot to build your get away home or use as a seasonal...
Cayuga Lake
,
Union Springs
,
New York
Lot For Sale
Acres: 1.100
Ad # 1837831
Sale Pending
$1,469,000
Dream here! Gorgeous Finger Lakes paradise with panoramic views...
Cayuga Lake
,
Interlaken
,
New York
3
3.0
Home Sale Pending
Sq Ft: 2728 Year: 2001 Acres: 57.000
Ad # 1824569
Sale Pending
$799,000
Incredibly private Cayuga lake living in the heart of Finger...
Cayuga Lake
,
Ovid
,
New York
3
3.0
Waterfront
Home Sale Pending
Sq Ft: 2791 Year: 2003 Acres: 1.100
Ad # 1774689
Sale Pending
$549,000
Cayuga Lakefront home with about 1 acre 40' of lake frontage and...
Cayuga Lake
,
Seneca Falls
,
New York
3
2.0
Waterfront
Home Sale Pending
Sq Ft: 1742 Year: 1964 Acres: 1.000
Ad # 1214727
Sale Pending
$520,000
42 acre farm in a prime location, minutes from Cornell & all...
Cayuga Lake
,
Groton
,
New York
2
2.0
Home Sale Pending
Sq Ft: 726 Year: 2008 Acres: 41.900
Ad # 1778648
Sale Pending
$465,000
Delayed negotiation Sept 26,2021 at 2:00 pm. Please submit POF...
Cayuga Lake
,
Seneca Falls
,
New York
3
2.0
Waterfront
Home Sale Pending
Sq Ft: 1550 Year: 1920 Acres: 0.450
Ad # 2013567
Sale Pending
$389,900
This is a gorgeous and versatile home in the most perfect...
Cayuga Lake
,
Ithaca
,
New York
5
3.0
Home Sale Pending
Sq Ft: 2649 Year: 1965 Acres: 1.040
Ad # 2065658
Sale Pending
$349,900
~ A Absolute Must See, 2 Bdrm., 1 1/2 Bath on Cayuga's West...
Cayuga Lake
,
Seneca Falls
,
New York
2
2.0
Waterfront
Home Sale Pending
Sq Ft: 512 Year: 1986 Acres: 0.050
Ad # 2031699
Sale Pending
$325,000
Prime waterfront location on the west side of Cayuga Lake Drive...
Cayuga Lake
,
Romulus
,
New York
2
1.0
Waterfront
Home Sale Pending
Sq Ft: 620 Year: 1958 Acres: 0.990
Ad # 1814276
Sale Pending
$164,900
Create your dream home right here, this property boasts some of...
Cayuga Lake
,
Trumansburg
,
New York
Waterfront
Lot Sale Pending
Acres: 1.840
Ad # 1242541
Sale Pending
$149,500
Build the home of your dreams surrounded by the serenity of the...
Cayuga Lake
,
Trumansburg
,
New York
Waterfront
Lot Sale Pending
Acres: 1.950
Ad # 1555554
Sale Pending
$110,000
A Finger Lakes village house looking for you to make it a home!...
Cayuga Lake
,
Interlaken
,
New York
3
2.0
Home Sale Pending
Sq Ft: 1872 Year: 1890 Acres: 0.300
Ad # 1837958
SPONSORED AD:
<
1
2
CLOSE
Give Feedback
Cayuga Lake Real Estate Specialist
A Team Of Cayuga Lake Specialists Working For You
Melissa Miller Fedrizzi
, RE/MAX IN MOTION
313 N. Meadow Street, Ithaca, NY 14850
+1 607-351-1995
View Listings
Contact Agent
