Home
> Monticello, Indiana (All Lakes)
-
0
$100,000
$100,000+
$200,000
$200,000+
$300,000
$300,000+
$400,000
$400,000+
$500,000
$500,000+
$600,000
$600,000+
$700,000
$700,000+
$800,000
$800,000+
$900,000
Any Price
Any Price
-
-
-
-
click to activate map

Monticello Homes For Sale

(1-20 of 51)
 Grid  Map
Tippecanoe River - White County Home For Sale in Monticello Indiana
For Sale
$39,900

Very nice well maintained mobile home sitting on the back of a...

Riverfront  Home  Monticello, Indiana

6591 E Chapmans Drive

2 1.0   Sf: 938   Yr: 1981  Acres: 0.225

Ad # 6351182
Tippecanoe River - White County Lot For Sale in Monticello Indiana
For Sale
$89,900

1.033 acre lot on Upper Lake Shafer with 49' of waterfrontage...

Riverfront  Lot  Monticello, Indiana

7053 E Washburn Drive

Acres: 1.033

Ad # 6323862
Tippecanoe River - White County Home For Sale in Monticello Indiana
Featured
For Sale
$299,000

Nestled at the end of a quiet lane, this solid lake home offers...

Riverfront  Home  Monticello, Indiana

5053 E Robin Court

2 1.0   Sf: 876   Yr: 1955  Acres: 0.130

Chris Thayer, Agent
Ad # 6126041
Tippecanoe River - White County Home For Sale in Monticello Indiana
Featured
For Sale
$124,900

Cozy Cabin with Potential! This two-bedroom fixer-upper is a...

Riverfront  Home  Monticello, Indiana

7004 E Red Maple Court

2 1.0   Sf: 768   Yr: 1974  Acres: 0.468

Jill Coble, Agent
Ad # 5722622
Lake Shafer Home For Sale in Monticello Indiana
Featured
For Sale
$639,900

Don't Miss this Beautifully Renovated Lake Shafer property!...

Lakefront  Home  Monticello, Indiana

5547 N West Shafer Drive

4 2.0   Sf: 2714   Yr: 1960  Acres: 0.280

Bart Hickman, Agent
Ad # 6264320
SPONSORED AD:
Lake Shafer Lot For Sale in Monticello Indiana
For Sale
$119,900

Main Lake Shafer lot with 97' of waterfrontage, steel driven...

Lakefront  Lot  Monticello, Indiana

2 W Shafer Drive

Acres: 0.208

Ad # 6343428
Lake Shafer Commercial For Sale in Monticello Indiana
For Sale
$164,900

2.01 acres of partially cleared B-2 Business Ground Adjacent to...

Commercial  Monticello, Indiana

0 West Shafer Drive

0 0.0   Yr: 1801  Acres: 2.010

Ad # 4577046
Lake Shafer Home For Sale in Monticello Indiana
Featured
For Sale
$299,900

Nestled in a cove, this lake house is ideally situated within...

Lakefront  Home  Monticello, Indiana

2412 N West Shafer Drive

3 3.0   Sf: 912   Yr: 1953  Acres: 0.230

Chris Thayer, Agent
Ad # 6152983
Lake Shafer Home For Sale in Monticello Indiana
For Sale
$624,900

Beautiful lake home right across from Indiana Beach with...

Lakefront  Home  Monticello, Indiana

2770 N Baer's Court

4 3.0   Sf: 2673   Yr: 1941  Acres: 0.470

Ad # 6317602
Lake Shafer Home For Sale in Monticello Indiana
For Sale
$850,000

This stunning new custom-built 3-bedroom, 3-bath lakefront...

Lakefront  Home  Monticello, Indiana

4033 Denver Court

3 3.0   Sf: 2707   Yr: 2025  Acres: 0.240

Ad # 6090025
Lake Shafer Home For Sale in Monticello Indiana
For Sale
$359,900

Beautiful waterfront home on Upper Lake Freeman includes 70 foot...

Lakefront  Home  Monticello, Indiana

1140 N Diamond Point Court

4 4.0   Sf: 2890   Yr: 1964  Acres: 0.378

Ad # 5908784
Lake Shafer Home For Sale in Monticello Indiana
Featured
For Sale
$585,000

RUSTIC, YET RESPLENDENT, this 2600 sq ft home, on an acre+ lake...

Lakefront  Home  Monticello, Indiana

8429 N Kiger Drive

3 3.0   Sf: 2632   Yr: 1989  Acres: 1.230

Sean Dekker, Agent
Ad # 6117173
Lake Shafer Home Sale Pending in Monticello Indiana
Sale Pending
$299,000

Location, Location, Location. This property offers convenient...

Home  Monticello, Indiana

2055 N Norway Trail

3 2.0   Sf: 1248   Yr: 2003  Acres: 3.500

Ad # 6124105
Lake Shafer Home For Sale in Monticello Indiana
For Sale
$279,900

2 bedroom Main Lake Shafer Cottage with Wide Panoramic Views of...

Lakefront  Home  Monticello, Indiana

5063 NW Shafer Drive

2 1.0   Sf: 368   Yr: 1940  Acres: 0.285

Ad # 6009931
Lake Shafer Home For Sale in Monticello Indiana
Featured
For Sale
$99,900

Rare opportunity on Lake Shafer!...

Home  Monticello, Indiana

6042 & 6050 N Harding Court

5 2.0   Sf: 1398   Yr: 1981  Acres: 0.108

Bart Hickman, Agent
Ad # 6136140
Lake Shafer Lot For Sale in Monticello Indiana
For Sale
$279,900

Lake Shafer Main Lake Lot with 24x48 Pole Barn Built by FBI. 2...

Lakefront  Lot  Monticello, Indiana

5051 NW Shafer Drive

Acres: 0.265

Ad # 6009932
Lake Shafer Home Sale Pending in Monticello Indiana
Featured
Sale Pending
$225,000

Focus on what is important! Enjoying the lake life with your...

Lakefront  Home  Monticello, Indiana

2371 G N Untalulti Drive

3 3.0   Sf: 1404   Yr: 1918  Acres: 0.050

Bart Hickman, Agent
Ad # 5935462
Lake Shafer Home For Sale in Monticello Indiana
Featured
For Sale
$619,900

Riverfront retreat, fully loaded and move-in ready! This...

Lakefront  Home  Monticello, Indiana

1602 N Brandywine Court

3 2.0   Sf: 2350   Yr: 1979  Acres: 0.980

Jill Coble, Agent
Ad # 6057335
Lake Shafer Home For Sale in Monticello Indiana
Featured
For Sale
$320,000

Start Showing Date: 6/7/2025 Immaculately maintained and truly...

Lakefront  Home  Monticello, Indiana

4319 E Penrod Dr

2 2.0   Sf: 832   Yr: 1940  Acres: 0.160

John Koppelmann, CRS, e-PRO, GRI, SRES, Agent
Ad # 6254457
Lake Shafer Commercial Sale Pending in Monticello Indiana
Featured
Sale Pending
$350,000

Lake Shafer Resort Property - A Prime Lakefront Retreat near...

Lakefront  Commercial  Monticello, Indiana

4945 E Indiana Beach Road

8 8.5   Sf: 2670   Yr: 1953  Acres: 0.240

John Koppelmann, CRS, e-PRO, GRI, SRES, Agent
Ad # 5746301